TQM, QSM, ISO have been the buzzwords of the global economy. Quality is still in demand today. Quality of what really??  

 

WHEN

THE SERVICE BELL RINGS.

by Dorian P. Landers

First published in 1993

   

I stay as a guest in many hotels and use service companies which adopt those acronyms.  I see it more in terms of ego-boosting for general managers and company executives than a real commitment to provide guests and patrons with genuine, efficient and attentive performance.

It reminds me of the smile campaigns of the 70s and early 80s, when the sole fact of having approved a program was satisfactory enough for many managers (including myself at the time).  You probably remember those as I do: the only people who were actually smiling were probably the suppliers or those thousands of badges and logo buttons.

Today, when I ask hospitality executives about quality of service, many assure me they have a TQM system in place. But when I check in and check out of their properties, talk to their guests or employees, I receive a very different message.  Obviously, something got garbled on the way down, you might say.

 

 

I always tell clients and operators:  the only valid standard measurement of a service is the customers level of satisfaction, not what the service provider says it is.

 

So what is complete customer care?

 Changing times

It starts by knowing what customer expectations truly are. The old adage that guests want service although very real, has somehow lost its kick.

Guests have different expectations based on the image projected by our companies. The rift is when management, employees and customers all have different expectations. Customers are a faithful bunch. One only has to satisfy their needs and exceed their expectations.

 As a guest I need a clean room, a TV that works, a commode that flushes, messages that are delivered in a timely manner; those are basic needs in hotels today.

Some of my expectations are that I will be genuinely greeted, made to feel as I am the only customer in town, checked in rapidly, my bathroom and room cleaned daily before 12 noon, and room service breakfast delivered within 15 minutes of ordering. I also expect a speedy and accurate checkout. More than this exceeds my expectations and will probably make me talk about the place forever.

Customer intimacy

How you understand your guests and patrons and what expectations they have of your company should define your entire strategy in terms of customer expectations.

Marketing is customer care taken at its root.  Dissociating the marketing function from a complete customer care program is like trying to grow grass, on a concrete slab – it will only take root in the cracks.

Your first and foremost step on the way to complete customer care is not to commission surveys and advertising polls.  It is this incredibly sophisticated tool called: TALK TO YOUR GUESTS!

Many general managers and executives never talk casually to their guests - one of them even admitted to me - "guests bother me".  His hotel was superb, his staff trained to the hilt - but the hotel had a dismal occupancy rate of 25%.  Guess what the problem was?  Learn from your guests.

Why is there seldom a waste paper basket in meeting rooms and banquet halls (one of many other consistent shortcomings)? Because we hoteliers do not talk to customers.  After many years of having meetings and seminars in various hotels, I have yet to come across one hotel manager or F&B director who would come to me and say: "What could we have done to make your meeting better'?" Instead, they use the old, run-of-the mill ask-and-don't listen questions and forms: "Did you enjoy your stay?  Was everything satisfactory?" The art of asking questions is the way to a customer's heart.

Time:   this is age of quick, fast information. Today everyone is used to zapping TV channels to switch to better programs; the same attitude applies to services.

People want to get things quick, and they should. As a guest, I get totally wild over the check-out procedure.  I want to pay my bill, but staff and procedures are seldom ready to accept my money.

I have been your guest during four entire days, you have computers and ample time to review the bill and to ensure that all is OK for my check-out.  Somehow, it seldom is, because nobody listens to the instructions I give upon checking in.  In a way, the old manual method where the chief cashier or Front Office Manager prepared each guest bill the night before a guest departure was actually working better.

I remember doing this as Front Office Manager in a ski resort three decades ago.  Every night I was to manually do the final bill for every customer who was to leave the next day.  Let me tell you, bills were ready the next morning and they were accurate - I could not blame it on the computer or another shift.  The buck stopped with me.

Develop a sense of urgency.  Your guests want an answer or action now!  Or be ready to be zapped out.

Customize!  Customize! 

All customers are individuals with specific needs.  Fill those needs and see them coming back.  Some hotels have gone to the extent of customizing rooms for long-staying guests, installing additional shelves, re-routing telephone lines and making other light modifications that truly make the guest quarters a home away from home.

The vision thing

A lot has been written about the power of vision by executives.  True enough, vision has awesome power, but not if it is imposed, only if it is shared.  Sharing a vision is, unfortunately, not as simplistic as dividing the cake into several portions and giving a piece to everyone.  Here is where most of us go astray: a view of a landscape cannot be divided without losing its reality.

Sharing a vision is to send every one to see the same movie, not to have a select few tell others how the film was. You will not share your vision by sending memos and having everyone write mission statements.  Only if you can talk to each employee and genuinely convince him or her of your passion for customer care will you stare sharing that vision.

 

  Do it right the first time !

I view the primary reasons for faiIure to produce superior service as a thorough lack of understanding of human behavior and a complete lack of commitment.  Great managers and great staff don't brag for hours about quality service: they make it happen, and to them it becomes as natural as bad service is for others.

Managers and staff alike often confuse facilities with customer service.  High occupancy rate and high profits in hotels and restaurants stem largely from superior execution not from a superior product.  Different execution styles in the same establishment can lead to considerable variations in bottom line results.

The way to win the game is to excel on all fronts, to be demonstrably better than other players in a way that truly thrills your customers. Defensive hotel executives talk about manufacturing industry leaders in those terms: "If only we were as flexible, as creative, a efficient, as responsive as they are.  All this TQM, it works for the manufacturing industry but not for service companies like hotels clubs and restaurants, because it is very subjective and customers are so fickle". I  say, get out and look around.  Top service operators exist everywhere!

What always amazes me about hotels is the difficulty people have to doing business with us hoteliers. We put so many barriers that it is miracle we manage to get people to book in our facilities.  Are your systems accessible and designed to make it easy for guests to do business with you? Or simply for your own operational convenience?

It starts with operators, 10 or 20 rings before you get a recorded message that everybody is too busy to attend to your business.  Operators seldom ask you what your needs are before transferring you, often to the wrong place or the wrong person. 

In that respect, I truly admire American Express.  The company has managed not only to train and empower their operators to take care of 90% of card members needs, but also to do it consistently with courtesy.  The card member, whatever the problem is, talks only to one staff member.  That person can help them for all questions - whether a problem with the account, lost card, an insurance query for a damaged purchase, or booking a concert ticket.  Nobody transfers you around, you are taken care of immediately by someone who can answer your need.  You put the phone down with that great feeling: something has been achieved; in a nutshell; you are more than satisfied. "The acid test of service quality is how to solve your customer's problems.  " (Leonard Barry, Texas A&M University).

There are basically four tenets to complete customer care:

bullet

Share an intimacy with customers

bullet

Look at time as an important amenity

bullet

Provide a climate of proactivity

bullet

Encourage and train for continuous improvement

Complete customer care is a genuine respect for the guest.  Superior service without consideration is missing the staircase to greatness.

A few years ago, I was working for a truly high quality hotel.  Service was one of the best money can buy and our staff was both friendly and exceptionally attentive to the guests they felt should have the right to stay there.

Others, often locals or Asian guests, were usually ignored or treated with condescendence.  What went wrong?  Although management had managed to share the vision of quality with the employees, it failed to relate it to customer care.

Complete customer care goes beyond guest satisfaction - it is a process designed to enthuse guests and employees, the internal as well as the external customers.

Controlling a service delivery process for uniformity of delivery usually leads to diminished rather than enhanced customer satisfaction.  Guests will not give you raving reviews for treating them in a robotized, mechanical, one-size-fits-all fashion, be it the best fashion!  People want to be served by people, not by machines.  They like the convenience of machines, but in today's high tech world, people also want more human interactions.

 

Ask yourself: "Do I really know what is happening with my guests or do I only manage?"

 

   Proactivity

Proactive behaviour is more than just taking initiative. It involves a notion of response-ability.  The ability to look for opportunities to formulate a response.

Reactive is putting out a fire - Pro-Active is fire prevention.

Reactive is bringing a glass of water to a guest who requests it- Pro-Active is placing an extra box of tissue on the bed table of a guest who appears to have a cold.

Reactive is taking care of flight reconfirmations at the Concierge counter - Pro-Active is the front desk clerk who asks the check-in guests if he would like to reconfirm his ticket now.

The great thing about proactivity is that most of the time, it costs nothing.

PLACE: Mandarin Oriental Hotel Hong Kong YEAR: 1991. I was staying there while I had a busy two days appointment schedule in the central district.  During lunch, one of my blazer buttons snapped.  I put the button in my pocket.  Fortunately, as I was not far from the hotel, I went back to my room to change the suit and casually left my jacket on a chair.  Guess what happened!  Yes, you are right!  When I came back at 6pm, the button had been sewn back in place.  Now, you will tell me: "It's the Mandarin Oriental in Hong Kong, they have more staff than we do, they can afford to do this." And I will tell you: "They became the Mandarin Hong Kong".

if you want to compete on customer care, can you afford not to do this?  Excuses may work with other executives and the head office; they don't work with guests and customers. You deliver or you don't.  Period.

  Fix it when if it fails

Ron Zemke wrote in The Service Edge: "...the blind spot in many service delivery systems is that they fail even to anticipate that something can go wrong”.

Excellent service - the kind that customers really talk about - comes from turning these moments of customer disappointment into customer delight, turning disservice into service, and aggravation into astonishment.  This is service recovery.

It is made up of all the actions you take to get a disappointed customer to a state of satisfaction with your organisation.

 Customers are not always upset when a problem arises - they are human too and know that a mishap can happen - they often become irate because nothing- is done about it.

Service recovery is important because it has a huge economic impact.  Using service recovery to heal upset customers is one of the best ways to keep them.  Consider that it takes five times as much money to get a new customer as it does to keep the one you have now.  It is clear: Service recovery does make money.

I know of some hotels where to offer a simple cup of coffee to a dissatisfied guest, waiters and captains need to go through several layers of bureaucracy and inquisition.  No wonder they don't do it.

Employees need freedom to act.  You need to develop with them appropriate ways to solve problems, and leave them initiative.  Training your staff to solve guest problems and to turn upset customers into satisfied guests is one of the highest impact activities you can think of.

  Train for the long term

As my ex-boss used to say, showing his forearm and pretending he was giving himself a jab: “it has to get in the blood! Once it circulates in there, it stays there!" So how do you get it in there in the first place?

Yes, by training and re-training. There is a lot of lip service about training. How do I know? Seriously, do you think you can enroll today in the Boston marathon and expect to finish it - I am not even talking about winning - without training for months and miles before hand. How can you expect to give your staff less than basic on the job training, and expect them to perform?  With so much turnover people are here today, gone tomorrow you say. 

There is considerable evidence that people stay longer where they receive training. Don't cut training when times are had: it is time to increase it, and boost productivity.  Top service provider typically devote three to five percent of their total paid hours to training. Some up to 10%. The point is: you need to do what you need to do to ensure complete customer care.

Pay for knowledge and continuous improvement and development.  The more staff train and educate themselves, the more you should pay.  Rewarding only seniority and longevity leads to complete sclerosis.

Cross training is a key to guest satisfaction in the hospitality industry.  Here is why.

#1 it improves the knowledge of employees to be able to solve customer problems on the spot,

#2 it helps employees understand the internal customer concept,

#3 it dramatically cuts on turnover due to boredom and lack of interest and

#4 it is the most affordable form of training you can get.

With continuous cross-training, employees not only learn new jobs but can also qualify for pay rises.

 

Provide the right climate

You need to set in place a climate that supports and encourages teamwork and leads to more satisfying, motivating and meaningful work for your employees.  You don't change a climate by bringing in radiators and air-conditioners.  You do it by making small positive changes daily and by being consistent.

That climate should be  one of continuous improvement, not just of achievement and then, let go. Introduce Kaizen, the Japanese notion of smalI, constant increments.  Make it a culture.  Reward maids who find better ways to clean bedrooms or stock supplies, and line cooks who find ways to help cut costs, improve recipes, etc.

Do you have your people selected, trained, empowered and rewarded for providing service that delights your customers?

If people are given ownership of their ideas and the means to be involved and bring their ideas about, there is a greater likelihood that the needed changes will come about. I know what many of you in Southeast Asia are saying: "All this sounds great and it probably works in the West, but it won't work here". Let me tell you ladies and gentlemen, Russia is not the West, but it is starting to work for them - same with China and Japan.

The key is that intrapreneurship (small bands of people who are responsible for reinventing services in organizations) motivates people.

People always have ideas.  The only element that is lacking is the prospect to carry out those ideas.  Either bosses seize the ideas for their own recognition, or ideas are rendered blunt or killed with: "It won't work, it's too expensive and so on." '

 The challenge to today's manager is to develop a breeding ground for those ideas to blossom

 

 

FOCUS ON IMPROVING THE ABILITY OF YOUR COMPANY TO MEET CUSTOMER NEEDS:

  1. Be a committed leader with a vision

  2. Encourage a high degree of teamwork

  3. Encourage people to go out of their way to solve guest problems

  4. Accept new ideas, new ways of operating and willing to experiment

  5. Be committed to do the best possible job

  6. Develop a total dedication to complete customer care

 

  There is no third chance

The key to re-defining the notion of customer care is the attitude and action displayed by management.  As the general manager of a recently opened 5 star property in KL was telling me: "More amenities do not bring more guests.  We must learn how to focus on what guests really want and satisfy them with true customer care ".

The same day, same hotel, a staff was telling me, commenting to the fact he was having difficulties obtaining coffee break refills from the kitchen: "In many places, people want to satisfy the guests, here the general idea is to satisfy the chef".

Same hotel again, a key executive was confiding: "We cannot give anything extra, you must understand that all has to be accounted for".  And further lowering his voice, referring to the GM: "You know how my boss is!"

Obviously, the message had been understood differently.  Management is always by example.  Nothing serves to give great training sessions to staff, motivational videos than to have managers give the wrong example.

  Complete Customer Care

bullet

Formulate an appropriate vision to be shared among all staff members

bullet

Instill a sense of ownership and passion for customer care in employees and executives

bullet

Define or re-define minimum standards expected for every activity undertaken by the hotel, taking customer responsiveness into consideration

bullet

Develop a method of self-checking, enabling staff and managers to improve on such standards and guarantee guests total dedication

bullet

Create a system that nurtures individual staff creativity and responsiveness to challenging situations

bullet

Develop managers and supervisors into coaches and mentors rather than controllers and wardens

bullet

Promote a scheme of productivity improvements reflecting total internal and external customer dedication

 

  Dorian Landers is a senior partner and Director of Hostasia Corp, an hospitality firm based in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

© Copyrights Dorian P. Landers 

 

  Point of View  Service Bell  Leadership  Max Sales  Rewards  Budgets